History of Wales / Timeline / The Age of Saints

c. 415 AD

Pelagius

Pelagius, a Briton, argues in Rome that people are free to choose good. His ideas challenge Saint Augustine and are argued over across Europe.

Picture: Pelagius in an early modern print, perhaps of the 1600s. · Unknown artist, Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Pelagius was a Briton, the first thinker from these islands whose name was known across the Christian world. In Rome, from about 380, he won a name for his strict and holy life, and he taught that every person has free will and is answerable for choosing the good.

WhenActive about 390 to 418
WhereBorn in Britain; taught in Rome
His nameTraditionally read as a Greek form of the Welsh name Morgan, ‘born of the sea’

A Briton in Rome#

Writers of his own day, among them Prosper of Aquitaine, called him a Briton. Pelagius stressed that people are free to choose, and he held that God is needed for salvation because God made every human being. His teaching on how a Christian should live set him against the greatest churchman of the age, Augustine of Hippo.

Saint Jerome, who thought him Irish, mocked him as ‘stuffed with Irish porridge’. In 415 a synod of bishops at Diospolis, in the Holy Land, heard his case and cleared him. But in 418 the bishops of Africa and the emperor Honorius pressed Pope Zosimus, who condemned him, and the Council of Carthage did the same.

His ideas come home#

His ideas were taken up in Britain, and about 429 Germanus of Auxerre crossed the sea to argue against them. More than a century later Dewi, by the account of his Life, spoke at the synod of Brefi against the same teaching.

Whatever the bishops of Africa thought of him, Pelagius was the first Briton whose thinking was argued over from Rome to the Holy Land.

A learned man#

Those who knew him described a tall and well-built man. He was highly educated, wrote and spoke both Latin and Greek with great fluency, and knew his theology well. In Rome he wrote to Paulinus of Nola, one of the most loved churchmen of the day. When Alaric and his Goths sacked Rome in 410, Pelagius and his follower Caelestius crossed to Carthage, and from there he went on to the Holy Land.

A friend in Jerusalem#

In Palestine he found a friend in John, bishop of Jerusalem, who called a council in July 415 to hear the arguments. It gave no verdict against him. At Diospolis in December he showed letters in his favour from leading churchmen, Augustine himself among them, for even his greatest opponent thought highly of his character. The synod’s words were plain: ‘we adjudge him to belong to the communion of the Catholic Church.’

We adjudge him to belong to the communion of the Catholic Church.

The Synod of Diospolis on Pelagius, 415

The Letter to Demetrias#

His own words survive in his Letter to Demetrias, written to a young Roman noblewoman, which sets out his belief that every person can choose to obey God’s commandments. He believed that everything God made was good, and he held to the baptism of children. The scholar Gerald Bonner saw his thinking partly as an answer to the Manichees, who taught that the material world was evil. For centuries afterwards his ideas were widely held, above all in Britain, Palestine and North Africa, though Augustine wrote book after book against them, in 412, in 414 and again in 415. In his last years Saint Cyril of Alexandria let him settle in Egypt.

Sources and further reading

Wikipedia ↗

The people

c. 354–c. 418

Pelagius

The first British writer (recorded)

A Briton who taught in Rome and argued with the greatest churchmen of his day. He held that every person is free to choose good, and is the first writer from Britain whose works survive.

Pelagius

Before and after

  1. Patrick taken by Irish raiders (recorded)

    Patrick, sixteen-year-old son of the deacon Calpurnius, is carried off from his home at Bannavem Taburniae by Irish raiders and sold as a slave. Welsh tradition holds that his home was Banwen, at the head of the Dulais valley.

    Patrick taken by Irish raiders
  2. Rome lets go (recorded)

    Roman rule in Britain ends. In the west, British kingdoms rise from the old tribal lands and the Brittonic language begins to become Welsh.

    Rome lets go
  3. The Alleluia victory (early chronicle:Life of Germanus, c. 480)

    Germanus of Auxerre leads the Britons, crying ‘Alleluia!’, to a victory without bloodshed. Tradition places it at Maes Garmon near Mold.

    The Alleluia victory
  4. Patrick goes to Ireland (recorded)

    Patrick goes back as a bishop to Ireland, the land where he was once a slave, and brings it the faith. Welsh tradition holds that he was born at Banwen, at the head of the Dulais valley.

    Patrick goes to Ireland

Written by Ifan Last updated