History of Wales / Timeline / The Stone Age

c. 230,000 BC

Neanderthals at Pontnewydd

Teeth found in Pontnewydd Cave, Denbighshire, are the oldest human remains in Wales.

Picture: The walled-up mouth of Pontnewydd Cave in its limestone crag. The wall and door were put in when the cave was an army store in the Second World War. · Llywelyn2000, CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Listen to this page 10 min · Read by Ada, a Microsoft computer voice

Long before there was a Wales, before even the last Ice Age, people lived in a cave above the River Elwy in what is now Denbighshire. They were early Neanderthals, and the teeth they left behind are the oldest human remains ever found in Wales. They make Pontnewydd, in the words of the museum that dug it, “a site of international importance”.

WhenAbout 230,000 years ago, in a warm spell between two ice ages
WherePontnewydd Cave (Ogof Bontnewydd), Cefn Meiriadog, near St Asaph, in the Elwy valley
WhoEarly Neanderthals: at least five people, from young children to adults
Found19 human teeth and a piece of a child’s jaw, over 1,200 stone tools, and the bones of the animals they lived among
Dug byAmgueddfa Cymru – Museum Wales, 1978 to 1995, led by Stephen Aldhouse-Green
Where the finds areAmgueddfa Cymru, Cardiff

The cave above the Elwy#

Pontnewydd means “new bridge”, after the hamlet by the river. The cave opens in a crag of limestone on the eastern side of the Elwy valley, a few miles above St Asaph, in the parish of Cefn Meiriadog. From its mouth the first people of Wales looked down on a green valley where horses, deer and rhinoceroses grazed.

The same limestone holds a whole family of caves along the river: Cae Gronw just above Pontnewydd, and the Cefn caves a little way off. Together they are one of the richest places in Britain for the story of the earliest people and the animals of the ice ages.

The Elwy valley. The cave is in the rocks near the middle of the picture.
The Elwy valley. The cave is in the rocks near the middle of the picture. · Picture: Llywelyn2000, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

The first tooth, 1874#

The cave first caught the eye of the Victorian geologists. William Boyd Dawkins looked into it and found the bones of animals, a hippopotamus among them. Then, in 1874, Thomas McKenny Hughes and the Reverend D. R. Thomas dug deeper. They found stone tools and a human tooth so big that the anatomist George Busk wrote that it was “of very large size”.

That tooth has since been lost. But it left a question hanging for a hundred years: were the people who made the tools buried in the same cave?

A site of international importance

Dr Elizabeth Walker, Amgueddfa Cymru, 2013

The great dig, 1978 to 1995#

In 1978 the National Museum of Wales set out to answer it. Its Palaeolithic Settlement of Wales project began its very first season at Pontnewydd, led by the archaeologist Stephen Green, later known as Stephen Aldhouse-Green, who went on to be the museum’s Keeper of Archaeology.

In 1980 the diggers found a human tooth. Chris Stringer of the Natural History Museum in London recognised it as the tooth of a Neanderthal, and in the words of the final report, it “transformed the whole nature of the project”. Scientists from many countries joined the work, and the digging went on, season after season, until 1995.

The final report, Neanderthals in Wales, edited by Stephen Aldhouse-Green, Rick Peterson and Elizabeth Walker, came out in 2012. Its verdict was plain: the work had pushed back the first known people in Wales from about 50,000 years ago to about 230,000.

Inside Pontnewydd Cave, dug down through the old floor layers by the museum’s team.
Inside Pontnewydd Cave, dug down through the old floor layers by the museum’s team. · Picture: Llywelyn2000, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

The teeth, and who they belonged to#

Deep inside the cave the team found 19 human teeth. They come from at least five people, and they range from young children to adults. The fullest find is a piece of the upper jaw of a child of about nine, with a well-worn milk tooth beside a big new adult molar that had only just come through.

X-rays showed something special about them. The teeth have very large pulp cavities and short roots, a shape called taurodontism, from the Greek word for a bull, because the teeth of cattle are made the same way. It is typical of Neanderthals, and it is one of the reasons the experts knew who these people were.

Early Neanderthal teeth from Krapina in Croatia, in an old drawing. The first Pontnewydd tooth was matched with these.
Early Neanderthal teeth from Krapina in Croatia, in an old drawing. The first Pontnewydd tooth was matched with these. · Picture: Wellcome Collection, CC BY 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

The very first report, in the journal Nature in 1981, compared the Pontnewydd tooth with the early Neanderthal teeth of Krapina in Croatia. A fuller study in 2015 looked closely at 17 of the teeth and found them most like the teeth from the Sima de los Huesos, the “pit of bones” at Atapuerca in Spain. The people of Pontnewydd belonged near the start of the Neanderthal line: the ancestors of the Neanderthals who lived across Europe tens of thousands of years later.

A model of a Neanderthal child at the Natural History Museum in Vienna. Children of an early Neanderthal people lived at Pontnewydd.
A model of a Neanderthal child at the Natural History Museum in Vienna. Children of an early Neanderthal people lived at Pontnewydd. · Picture: Jakub Hałun, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

How old are they?#

Nothing at Pontnewydd could be dated by radiocarbon, which only reaches back about 50,000 years. Instead the scientists used three other clocks. They dated flints that had been heated in a fire, by thermoluminescence; the stalagmite that grew over the layers, by uranium-series; and the enamel of the teeth themselves, by electron spin resonance.

The first results, in 1981, pointed to around 200,000 years. With all the dates gathered, the national museum puts the teeth at about 230,000 years old, and the scientists who studied them in 2015 at about 225,000. They lived in the middle of a warm spell between two ice ages.

Their tools#

The people of Pontnewydd were skilled toolmakers. The cave has given over 1,200 stone artefacts. Among them are some forty handaxes, the classic tear-shaped tool of the Acheulean toolmakers, and many tools made by the Levallois method: the maker shaped a block of stone first so that one blow would strike off a flake of exactly the form wanted. There are scrapers for working hides and wood, knives, and one fine pointed tool of the kind called Mousterian.

A handaxe of the same kind, the Acheulean, found in southern England. About forty were found at Pontnewydd, most of them in hard volcanic rock.
A handaxe of the same kind, the Acheulean, found in southern England. About forty were found at Pontnewydd, most of them in hard volcanic rock. · Picture: Tim Sheerman-Chase, CC BY 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

What sets Pontnewydd apart is the stone. Most early tools in Britain are of flint, but here flint is little more than a tenth of the whole. The rest are hard volcanic rocks, most of them from Eryri. Glaciers had carried pebbles of them down into the valley, and the toolmakers picked them out of the gravels. They chose with care: the denser lavas for handaxes, the finer flint, chert and tuff for the sharp, neat scrapers.

Life in the Elwy valley 230,000 years ago#

The bones in the cave show the world these people knew. Wolf, fox, bear, lion and a big cat the size of a leopard hunted in the valley. Horses, red deer, reindeer, wild cattle or bison, and a rhinoceros of the woodlands grazed there, with beavers in the river and lemmings in the grass. The oldest record of the wolf anywhere in Britain comes from this cave.

Some of the animal bones carry the cut marks of butchery, so they were the remains of the people’s meals. Children grew up here among adults: a small band living by the hunt, making their tools by the fire and sheltering in the cave mouth. At other times bears used the cave as a den.

A Neanderthal hunter at work, as the Neanderthal Museum in Germany shows him.
A Neanderthal hunter at work, as the Neanderthal Museum in Germany shows him. · Picture: Neanderthal-Museum, Mettmann, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

We do not know whether they buried their dead in the cave. Long afterwards, mudflows and the meltwater of later ice ages swept the old floors deeper into the cave and mixed them up, so any graves were broken long ago.

The caves nearby#

Pontnewydd is not alone. Along the river are the Cefn caves, famous since the antiquary John Leland wrote of them in the 1530s. Charles Darwin and Adam Sedgwick may have looked into them on their geology tour in August 1831, and the next year the Reverend Edward Stanley dug out bones of the straight-tusked elephant, the rhinoceros and the hippopotamus, animals of a later warm spell about 125,000 years ago. Stanley saw Pontnewydd too, but left it untouched.

In 1870 the Cefn caves were in the newspapers for a stranger reason: a chimney sweep from Rhyl claimed he had killed a crocodile-like creature living in the cave. In truth the animal had died in a travelling menagerie in Rhyl.

Looking out from a cave in the woods of the Elwy valley, the protected site that holds the Cefn caves.
Looking out from a cave in the woods of the Elwy valley, the protected site that holds the Cefn caves. · Picture: Llywelyn2000, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

The museum dug at Cefn too, in 1982 to 1984, and dated its oldest floor deposits to nearly 230,000 years, the same age as the people of Pontnewydd. Just above Pontnewydd is the small cave of Cae Gronw, dug in 1979, 1980 and 1985, where cave bears and arctic lemmings lived much later, around 33,000 years ago.

Further south, later Neanderthals left their handaxes in Coygan Cave in Carmarthenshire between about 60,000 and 35,000 years ago. And on Gower, about 33,000 years ago, modern humans buried the young man known as the Red Lady of Paviland.

Why it matters#

Pontnewydd is one of only three places in Britain, with Boxgrove and Swanscombe in England, to have given up the remains of such early people. It is the only place in Wales where people of this age have been found, and it shows that the land of Wales was a home to people more than 200,000 years ago.

The story of Wales does not begin with the Romans, nor even with the first farmers. It begins here, in a cave above the Elwy, with a child of nine and a family of hunters.

The cave today#

In the Second World War the army used Pontnewydd as a store for landmines and depth charges, and built the stone wall, steel doors and guard chamber that still close its mouth. The cave is on private land and is not open to visitors. The teeth, the jaw, the tools and the animal bones are in the care of Amgueddfa Cymru – Museum Wales in Cardiff, and many of them can be seen on its Collections Online.

Sources and further reading

Wikipedia ↗

Before and after

  1. The Red Lady of Paviland (archaeology)

    A young man is buried in red ochre in a Gower cave. Found in 1823 and first thought to be a woman, he is Britain’s oldest known ceremonial burial.

    The Red Lady of Paviland
  2. Art in Kendrick’s Cave (archaeology)

    Ice Age people on the Great Orme decorate a horse’s jaw with zigzag lines, the oldest known decorated object in Wales.

    Art in Kendrick’s Cave

Written by Ifan Last updated