On 3 August 1967 the Tribunal of inquiry into Aberfan gave its report. Its first finding was plain: “Blame for the disaster rests upon the National Coal Board.”Source1967 speech on the Aberfan Inquiry ↗David Gibson-Watt MP, House of CommonsTells of the 1963 letters from Mr Jones, the Borough Engineer, and quotes the Tribunal’s first finding: “Blame for the disaster rests upon the National Coal Board.”SourceAberfan disaster ↗WikipediaAt about 9.15 on the morning of 21 October 1966 waterlogged colliery spoil from Tip 7 slid down the hillside onto Pantglas Junior School and the houses near it; 144 people died, 116 of them children and 28 adults, and in the school 109 children and five teachers; the Tribunal was chaired by Lord Justice Edmund Davies, born and schooled in nearby Mountain Ash, and appointed in late October 1966; it heard 136 witnesses over 76 days and reported on 3 August 1967; it found that the disaster could have been prevented, censured nine Coal Board employees, and said that Lord Robens had misled the public about the springs beneath the tip; neither the Coal Board nor any of its staff was prosecuted or fined.
| Chair | Lord Justice Edmund Davies of Mountain Ash |
|---|---|
| Hearings | 76 days and 136 witnesses |
| Report | 3 August 1967 |
| Finding | The disaster could have been prevented |
A judge from the valley#
The Tribunal was chaired by Lord Justice Edmund Davies, who had been born and schooled in nearby Mountain Ash. It sat for 76 days and heard 136 witnesses.SourceAberfan disaster ↗WikipediaAt about 9.15 on the morning of 21 October 1966 waterlogged colliery spoil from Tip 7 slid down the hillside onto Pantglas Junior School and the houses near it; 144 people died, 116 of them children and 28 adults, and in the school 109 children and five teachers; the Tribunal was chaired by Lord Justice Edmund Davies, born and schooled in nearby Mountain Ash, and appointed in late October 1966; it heard 136 witnesses over 76 days and reported on 3 August 1967; it found that the disaster could have been prevented, censured nine Coal Board employees, and said that Lord Robens had misled the public about the springs beneath the tip; neither the Coal Board nor any of its staff was prosecuted or fined.

A warning in 1963#
The inquiry was told of the letters Mr Jones, the Borough Engineer, had written about the tips in 1963.Source1967 speech on the Aberfan Inquiry ↗David Gibson-Watt MP, House of CommonsTells of the 1963 letters from Mr Jones, the Borough Engineer, and quotes the Tribunal’s first finding: “Blame for the disaster rests upon the National Coal Board.”
The report called what it had heard “a terrifying tale of bungling ineptitude”, and described those to blame as “not villains but decent men, led astray by foolishness or by ignorance or by both in combination”.SourceThe Aberfan Disaster, 21 October 1966 ↗UK Government, from the Report of the Tribunal (HMSO, 1967)Quotes the report: “a terrifying tale of bungling ineptitude”, and “Not villains but decent men, led astray by foolishness or by ignorance or by both in combination”.

After the report#
Nine Coal Board employees were censured, and the Tribunal found that Lord Robens had misled the public about the springs beneath the tip. Even so, neither the Board nor any of its staff was ever prosecuted or fined.SourceAberfan disaster ↗WikipediaAt about 9.15 on the morning of 21 October 1966 waterlogged colliery spoil from Tip 7 slid down the hillside onto Pantglas Junior School and the houses near it; 144 people died, 116 of them children and 28 adults, and in the school 109 children and five teachers; the Tribunal was chaired by Lord Justice Edmund Davies, born and schooled in nearby Mountain Ash, and appointed in late October 1966; it heard 136 witnesses over 76 days and reported on 3 August 1967; it found that the disaster could have been prevented, censured nine Coal Board employees, and said that Lord Robens had misled the public about the springs beneath the tip; neither the Coal Board nor any of its staff was prosecuted or fined.
Sources and further reading





