History of Wales / Long reads

Long read

Slate, solidarity and survival: reading the Penrhyn dispute

From 1900 to 1903 the quarrymen of Bethesda stood out against the owner of the largest slate quarry in the world, in the longest dispute in British industrial history. Their story is told here through the papers that survive: a manager’s notice, the union’s nine requests, a card in a window, the debates in Parliament, an appeal for W. J. Parry, and the archives where the rest are kept.

Picture: The huge stepped galleries of Penrhyn slate quarry at Bethesda, in a hand-coloured photochrom print of about 1900 · Photoglob Zürich, Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Listen to this long read 24 min · Read by Ada, a Microsoft computer voice

On the morning of 22 November 1900 some 2,800 men walked out of the Penrhyn quarry at Bethesda. Most of them would not work there again for three years. It became the longest dispute in the industrial history of Britain. It began as a quarrel about work, and became a struggle over something larger: whether the quarrymen of Dyffryn Ogwen could choose men from among themselves to speak for them.

Much of the story survives on paper: a manager’s notice, a union pamphlet, a card in a window, the debates of Parliament, a fund appeal, and hundreds of letters and newspaper cuttings in the archives of Bangor and Caernarfon. This long read follows those documents, and asks of each one who made it, for whom, and what it can and cannot tell us. The short story of the dispute is on its own page; this is the longer reading.

WhereThe Penrhyn quarry, Bethesda, Dyffryn Ogwen
Began22 November 1900
EndedNovember 1903
Men outAbout 2,800
The questionThe right to choose their own spokesmen, and a union the owner would recognise
Their championWilliam John Parry of Coetmor, first secretary of the North Wales Quarrymen’s Union
RememberedA slate memorial at Jerusalem Chapel, Bethesda (2000); a World Heritage landscape (2021)

The rock that roofed the world#

Slate tied the mountains of north-west Wales to the growing towns and cities of the world. By the 1890s the Welsh slate industry employed about 17,000 men and made almost half a million tons of slate a year, around a third of all the roofing slate used in the world. Welsh slate roofed Westminster Hall, the Royal Exhibition Building in Melbourne and Copenhagen City Hall.

At the end of the 1800s the Penrhyn quarry was the largest slate quarry in the world: nearly a mile long and 1,200 feet deep, and worked by nearly 3,000 men. Its galleries rose up the mountain like giant steps. Its slate went down the Penrhyn Quarry Railway to Port Penrhyn at Bangor, and out by sea.

The Penrhyn quarry about 1850, its galleries cut like giant steps into the mountain, with men working and blasting on every level.
The Penrhyn quarry about 1850, its galleries cut like giant steps into the mountain, with men working and blasting on every level. · Picture: Thomas Hosmer Shepherd, National Library of Wales, Public domain, Wikimedia Commons

In 2021 UNESCO inscribed the Slate Landscape of Northwest Wales on the World Heritage List. It recognises the quarries, the water systems, the railways and the harbours, and also the skill of the quarrymen, whose knowledge went with them to the slate industries of the United States, continental Europe and Ireland. It names the workers’ villages too, with ‘their characteristic chapels and churches, band-rooms, schools, libraries and meeting-places’ and their ‘strong minority language’.

The Penrhyn estate’s wealth had an older root as well. Richard Pennant, who opened the quarry at Caebraichycafn in 1782, was also the absentee owner of six sugar plantations in Jamaica worked by more than six hundred enslaved Africans, and he put the money they made into roads, docks and the slate quarry. He died in 1808. The Lord Penrhyn of the great dispute was a later owner, George Sholto Gordon Douglas-Pennant (1836–1907), the second Baron Penrhyn, who took charge of the quarry in 1885.

Port Penrhyn at Bangor, built to send the slate of the Penrhyn quarry out to the world.
Port Penrhyn at Bangor, built to send the slate of the Penrhyn quarry out to the world. · Picture: Reading Tom, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

The bargain: skilled men and their own rock#

The quarrymen were not simply hands. The skilled men worked in small partnerships, a ‘bargain gang’ of three to eight: rockmen who blasted the rock, a splitter who split the blocks with hammer and chisel, and a dresser who trimmed the slates. On the first Monday of each month a steward let each gang a stretch of rock, a bargain, at an agreed price.

Because no two stretches of rock were alike, the price took the rock into account: poor rock earned a higher rate, good rock a lower one. The bargain protected the men’s earnings against the luck of the rock, and let them think of themselves as contractors rather than employees. It was a source of pride and independence, and it was at the heart of every quarrel that followed.

Their world was Welsh-speaking and Nonconformist. Out of small wages they built chapels and paid towards schools and colleges; the historian John Davies wrote that their pennies helped found the University of Wales. The owners and the top managers of the great quarries were mostly English-speaking, Anglican and Conservative, and talks between the two sides often needed an interpreter.

The Penrhyn quarry from Braich Melyn, photographed by John Thomas about 1885.
The Penrhyn quarry from Braich Melyn, photographed by John Thomas about 1885. · Picture: John Thomas, National Library of Wales, Public domain, Wikimedia Commons

A union of their own, 1874#

On 27 April 1874, after a month of talks among quarrymen from Dinorwig and their supporters, the North Wales Quarrymen’s Union was founded at the Queen’s Hotel in Caernarfon. Disputes at Dinorwig and at Penrhyn that same year both ended in victory for the men, and by May 1878 the union had 8,368 members.

One of its founders, Morgan Richards, described in 1876 what work had been like when he started in the quarries forty years before:

I well remember the time when I was myself a child of bondage; when my father and neighbours, as well as myself, had to rise early, to walk five miles before six in the morning, and the same distance home after six in the evening; to work hard from six to six.

Morgan Richards, 1876

From 1874 to 1885 the men at Penrhyn had a quarry committee to bring their grievances to the management, and the members for Wales told Parliament in 1903 that in those years there had not been a single strike.

William John Parry of Coetmor#

The union’s first secretary was a Bethesda man, William John Parry, born there on 28 September 1842. He was an accountant by training, a deacon of Bethesda chapel, and a man of ideas. He took a leading part in the creation of the union in 1874, was its first secretary and afterwards its president for some years, and in 1879 went to see the slate quarries of the United States at the union’s request.

‘W. J. Parry, Coetmor, Bethesda’: the portrait printed in his own book on the quarries and the quarrymen, 1897.
‘W. J. Parry, Coetmor, Bethesda’: the portrait printed in his own book on the quarries and the quarrymen, 1897. · Picture: from W. J. Parry, Chwareli a Chwarelwyr (1897), Public domain, Wikimedia Commons

His thinking reached well beyond the quarry. In 1882, at the National Eisteddfod, he read a paper to the Cymmrodorion on local, provincial and imperial government, proposing provincial councils for Wales and Scotland and the reform of the House of Lords. It was thought too revolutionary to print, and only appeared in the Society’s Transactions in 1917–18. He was one of the founders of the newspaper Y Werin in 1885 and its first editor, sat on the first Caernarfonshire County Council in 1889, and was its chairman in 1892–93.

He wrote again and again on the quarrymen’s cause, in Welsh and English, in Yr Herald Cymraeg, Y Genedl Gymreig and the North Wales Observer, and in books: Chwareli a Chwarelwyr in 1897 and The Penrhyn Lock-out, 1900–1901: Statement and Appeal in 1901. The People’s Collection calls him ‘well-respected and an important leader of men’. His own full life story is on his page.

The first lock-out, 1896–97#

The new Lord Penrhyn set out to manage the quarry his own way. One of his first acts was to set aside the workmen’s committee, and in 1886 he made Emilius Alexander Young his chief manager. In September 1896 the suspension of 57 members of the union committee and 17 other men led to a stoppage of eleven months. The managers called it a strike; the men said they had been locked out.

The Board of Trade helped to settle it in 1897. The men went back in August of that year, largely on Lord Penrhyn’s terms, with only a limited right to bring their grievances forward in sections. Both words, ‘strike’ and ‘lock-out’, tell part of what happened in both disputes. The men chose to stop work; the owner also shut men out and decided who might come back.

During that first stoppage W. J. Parry led a group that bought the Pantdreiniog quarry in the middle of Bethesda and took on locked-out men, choosing married men so that the wages would reach their families.

Document one: the notice of 6 November 1900#

In April 1900 Young announced that union contributions would no longer be collected at the quarry. On 26 October there was violence against contractors who had taken a bargain on one of the galleries. Lord Penrhyn pressed charges against 26 quarrymen and dismissed them before their case was heard. When they came before the magistrates at Bangor, the quarrymen marched from Bethesda to Bangor in their thousands to stand by them, and they marched home again in peace. Only six of the twenty-six were found guilty, and fined.

The day of the march, the manager posted this notice.

PENRHYN QUARRY.

NOTICE.

Inasmuch as a number of the Penrhyn Quarry Employees has during the last fortnight actively participated in certain acts of violence and intimidation against some of their fellow-workmen and officials, and to-day nearly all the Employees have left their work without leave, Notice is hereby given that such Employees are suspended for 14 days.

E. A. YOUNG

PORT PENRHYN,
Bangor, November 6th, 1900.

The notice of 6 November 1900, signed by the chief manager, E. A. Young, at Port Penrhyn. Set out here word for word from the printed notice, which WJEC reproduces as source B14 in its GCSE history sources. See the printed notice (WJEC, page 72)

Reading the evidence. The notice records what the management announced and the reason it gave. Look at its wording: ‘a number’ of employees were accused of violence and intimidation, but it is ‘such Employees’, nearly all of them, who are suspended. An accusation about some men became a punishment for the whole quarry. The notice is the management’s account; on its own it does not prove what any one of the suspended men had done.

A question to explore: what other evidence would you need to judge whether the suspension was fair? The court record, which found twenty of the twenty-six not guilty, is one place to start.

22 November 1900: ‘leave the quarry quietly’#

The men went back on 19 November, but eight galleries, the ponciau, were not let out, which left 800 men without a bargain. On 22 November about 2,000 quarrymen arrived at the quarry as usual and refused to start work until the 800 had their bargains too. Young’s answer was an ultimatum: ‘Go on working or leave the quarry quietly.’ They left.

A month later new terms were offered. Seventy-seven men accepted them, and 1,707 refused. By the middle of January 1901 the quarry was closed, and the dock workers of Port Penrhyn were dismissed too.

Rhes Cilfodan, a row of quarrymen’s houses in Bethesda.
Rhes Cilfodan, a row of quarrymen’s houses in Bethesda. · Picture: Eric Jones, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Document two: what the men asked for#

What did the quarrymen want? W. J. Parry set it out in nine points in his book of 1901, written to explain the dispute to the people of Britain and to appeal for their help.

WHAT THE UNION WANTS

  1. The right freely to elect spokesmen from the ranks of the men in the quarry to discuss grievances with the management from time to time.
  2. The right of the men during the dinner hour to discuss matters among themselves in the quarry.
  3. The reinstatement of certain victimised leaders.
  4. The establishment of a minimum wage.
  5. The punishment of unjustifiable conduct on the part of the foremen and officials towards the men.
  6. The introduction, experimentally, of a system of co-operative piece-work in place of work hitherto done under contract.
  7. The humanising of the harsh rules of discipline, and the reduction of the punishments for breaches of them.
  8. The reintroduction of the annual holiday on May 1st.
  9. More democratic control of the Quarry Sick Club.
The nine points, from W. J. Parry’s The Penrhyn Lock-out, 1900–1901: Statement and Appeal (London, 1901), as reproduced by WJEC (source B3). See the page (WJEC, page 66)

Reading the evidence. This is the union’s own case, written by one of its leaders to win support, so it puts the men’s requests in the best light. Even so, look at what is on the list. There is no demand to run the quarry. The first two points ask only for the right to choose spokesmen and to talk among themselves at dinner time. A minimum wage, fairer discipline, a holiday on the first of May, a say in their own sick club: these are the requests of men who wanted to be treated as partners in their work.

In Parliament two years later the member for Anglesey, Ellis Griffith, put the same point plainly: what the men asked for was a committee ‘to consider the grievances and to represent them’, and that, he told the House, was a legitimate end.

A question to explore: how would Lord Penrhyn’s managers have described the same nine points? Bangor University’s Penrhyn papers keep the management’s side of the correspondence.

Document three: ‘Nid oes bradwr yn y tŷ hwn’#

On 11 June 1901 the quarry reopened to men approved by the quarry office. About 400 went back, each given a gold sovereign and promised a rise of five per cent. Those who stayed out called it ‘punt y gynffon’, the tail’s pound.

That same evening, at a crowded meeting, the strikers decided to print a card to be shown in the window of every striker’s home. Its words became the most famous of the whole dispute.

NID OES

BRADWR

YN Y TY HWN.

The words of the window card, set out as the card prints them: ‘There is no traitor in this house’. A card kept by Caernarfon Record Office (Gwynedd Archives) can be seen on People’s Collection Wales. See the card (People’s Collection Wales, item 8137)
A card from the dispute still in the window of No. 2 Fron Haul, Bethesda, when this photograph was taken in 2006.
A card from the dispute still in the window of No. 2 Fron Haul, Bethesda, when this photograph was taken in 2006. · Picture: Eric Jones, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Most of the cards stayed in the windows of Bethesda for more than two years. When a card came down, it meant that another quarryman had gone back to work. The union organiser D. R. Daniel urged the men to keep apart from those who had returned, and the radical Welsh papers Y Werin and Yr Eco Cymraeg printed their names.

Reading the evidence. The card is a public promise, made by a whole household, in Welsh, in the window where every neighbour would see it. It shows how a dispute at work came into the home, and how a community kept its courage through two hard winters. ‘Bradwr’, traitor, is the campaign’s word: it tells us how the strikers felt about breaking ranks, not why each man who went back did so. A card cannot tell us what every member of the family thought, nor what it cost the households whose windows were bare.

A question to explore: how might the same card have looked to a striker, to a man who had gone back, and to a child walking to school past both houses?

Holding together#

The quarrymen were not left alone. Money and gifts came from working people across Britain. A firm in Ashton-under-Lyne sent a Christmas pudding weighing two and a half tons, and the children of Bethesda were still singing about it years later.

Above all, they sang for their supper. Three choirs of quarrymen went on tour to raise money for the families at home, and the newspapers of March 1901 followed them to Brighton, Mountsorrel and London. In the south, the chapels held concerts for them: a programme survives for one held at Tabernacle Chapel, Morriston, on 21 November 1901, in aid of the Penrhyn Quarrymen’s Distress Fund. W. J. Parry chaired the Penrhyn Relief Fund.

Parry also found work. In March 1901 he reopened Pantdreiniog as a workers’ co-operative, and in its first month it made a small profit and paid wages of 32 shillings and sixpence a week. In 1903, with the union’s money, he brought Pantdreiniog, Moel Faban and Tanybwlch together as the Bethesda Co-operative Quarries, incorporated on 3 October 1903, with Parry as managing director.

Many had to leave. By 1902 about 700 men had gone back to the quarry, and many more had left the valley to find work, most of them in the coalfield of south Wales, sending money home to families who stayed. The women of Bethesda held the homes together, and the Penrhyn ladies’ choir sang to raise money for the relief. Historians are now looking more closely at what the dispute meant for the women and the wider community, whose part the older histories passed over.

Document four: Bethesda in Parliament, 1903#

On 5 March 1903 William Jones, the member for Arfon, asked the House of Commons to debate ‘the severe privation and loss arising from the struggle in the Penrhyn quarry district’. His speech, printed in Hansard, is one of the fullest records of the dispute from the men’s side.

He gave the House the numbers. Of the 2,800 men who had worked in the quarry, about 1,400 had gone away, about 800 were at home unable to find work, about 100 had died during the struggle, and about 500 were at work in the quarry. He told of men working in south Wales to keep two homes going, and of families who, ‘when the pinch of hunger came, were too proud to ask for alms or relief’.

The men were amongst the most law-abiding citizens on the face of the globe. Everybody knew how they had built their own chapels and schools.

William Jones, member for Arfon, House of Commons, 5 March 1903

He read out the words of the chairman of the county’s Standing Joint Committee, a quarry owner himself: ‘The whole community deserved the greatest possible credit for the self-restraint they had shown considering the feeling that had existed.’

On 27 April 1903 Herbert Asquith moved that the House condemn the government for not stepping in to settle ‘the industrial dispute at Bethesda’. In that debate Ellis Griffith gave the line that Bethesda remembers:

Lord Penrhyn may own a quarry, but he does not own the men.

Ellis Griffith, member for Anglesey, House of Commons, 27 April 1903

Reading the evidence. Hansard is a record of what was said, not a judgement on whether it was true. William Jones spoke for the quarrymen, and other members spoke for Lord Penrhyn. But the speeches give figures, names and the words of county reports that are hard to find anywhere else, and they show that the dispute in one Welsh valley had become a question for the whole kingdom.

Document five: the appeal for W. J. Parry, 1903#

In 1901 Parry wrote in The Clarion, a socialist weekly, that the dispute was costing lives in Bethesda, and he laid the blame on the quarry owner. Lord Penrhyn sued him for libel. At the High Court on 10 to 12 March 1903 the jury found for Lord Penrhyn, and Parry was ordered to pay £500 in damages, with costs.

His friends did not leave him to carry it alone. A W. J. Parry Penrhyn Libel Fund was set up, and by the autumn of 1903 the newspapers reported that it had raised £2,960. On 30 September 1903 the fund published an appeal, now kept in the Welsh Library at Bangor University, thanking those who had given and asking for more help towards what Parry still owed. It is a different fund from the Penrhyn Relief Fund for the quarrymen, which Parry chaired.

Reading the evidence. An appeal is written to raise money, so it presents Parry in the best light; it is not an audited account, and it does not settle whether the court was right. What it does show is that thousands of ordinary people were ready to give to a man who had spoken out for them. An appeal, the court record and Lord Penrhyn’s own papers, which keep the cuttings from The Clarion and his solicitors’ letters, would each tell a different part of the same story.

A question to explore: what can a fund appeal tell us that a court record cannot?

November 1903#

By the autumn of 1903 the relief money was running out. In November the men who were still out voted to go back. Lord Penrhyn’s papers keep 76 newspaper cuttings on the end of the dispute, many saying that it had in truth ended long before, when work slowly started again in the quarry. The men returned on the owner’s terms, and the union was still not recognised. Many of those who had been prominent in the union were not taken back, and many who had left never returned.

In the end it was not hearts or minds which decided the issue, but the empty stomachs of the strikers’ families. The men went back to work in November 1903, their union still unrecognised.

John Davies, historian

A note on the date. The published accounts do not agree on the day the dispute ended. Cadw’s learning resource on the slate landscape gives 8 November 1903; the centenary pamphlet of 2003, now in Amgueddfa Cymru, commemorates 14 November 1903. This page gives the month rather than choose a day without the evidence to decide between them.

What the dispute left#

The quarry never again employed so many: by 1907 its workforce was down to 1,800. While Penrhyn was idle, French slate makers sent more than twice as much slate to Britain, and the Welsh slate industry entered a long decline.

But Bethesda did not forget, and Wales did not forget Bethesda. T. Rowland Hughes, a quarryman’s son from Llanberis, told the story of the lock-out in his novel Chwalfa (1946), through the Ifans family of the quarry town he called Llechfaen. It was made for television by the BBC in the 1960s and staged by Theatr Genedlaethol Cymru in 2016. Caradog Prichard, born in Bethesda in 1904, the son of a quarryman, carried the voice of the valley into Un Nos Ola Leuad.

In 2000, a hundred years after the walk-out, a slate memorial was raised in the grounds of Jerusalem Chapel in Bethesda. In 2003, at the centenary of the end, the Transport and General Workers’ Union unveiled a plaque on it in memory of all who took part.

The slate memorial to the Great Strike in the grounds of Jerusalem Chapel, Bethesda, unveiled in 2000.
The slate memorial to the Great Strike in the grounds of Jerusalem Chapel, Bethesda, unveiled in 2000. · Picture: Eirian Evans, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Its words, in Welsh and English, are the last word of the dispute, and the proudest:

The plaque on the memorial: ‘Streic Fawr Penrhyn 1900 – 1903. Great Strike Penrhyn. Da ni yma o hyd. We are still here.’
The plaque on the memorial: ‘Streic Fawr Penrhyn 1900 – 1903. Great Strike Penrhyn. Da ni yma o hyd. We are still here.’ · Picture: Meirion, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

A chronology#

1782Richard Pennant opens the quarry at Caebraichycafn
27 April 1874The North Wales Quarrymen’s Union is founded at Caernarfon; W. J. Parry is its first secretary
1874A dispute at Penrhyn ends in victory for the men
1885–1886A new owner takes charge; E. A. Young becomes chief manager
September 1896 – August 1897The first lock-out, eleven months
April 1900Union contributions are no longer collected at the quarry
6 November 1900The notice suspends the men for 14 days
22 November 1900About 2,800 men walk out
January 1901The quarry is closed
March 1901Parry opens Pantdreiniog as a co-operative
11 June 1901The quarry reopens; about 400 go back
21 November 1901A concert for the quarrymen at Tabernacle Chapel, Morriston
5 March 1903William Jones raises the dispute in the Commons
10–12 March 1903Lord Penrhyn’s libel action against Parry
27 April 1903Asquith’s motion on the dispute at Bethesda
30 September 1903The W. J. Parry Penrhyn Libel Fund appeal
3 October 1903The Bethesda Co-operative Quarries are incorporated
November 1903The men vote to return; the union is still unrecognised
2000The slate memorial at Jerusalem Chapel
2021The Slate Landscape of Northwest Wales becomes a World Heritage Site

Follow the evidence further#

Bangor University keeps ‘PQS: Penrhyn Correspondence – Quarry Strike’, 411 items from 1874 to 1903 on the disputes of 1896–97 and 1900–03, and Lord Penrhyn’s own bundles of letters and cuttings in the Penrhyn papers. The online catalogue describes them; it is not a transcript of them.

Gwynedd Archives at Caernarfon keep the records of the North Wales Quarrymen’s Union, with its minute books, accounts and papers on the Penrhyn strikes of 1896 to 1904, and the window card shown above. The National Library of Wales holds letters, circulars and pamphlets of the disputes (NLW MS 8746E), and its free Welsh Newspapers site has Y Werin, Yr Herald Cymraeg and the other papers of the time, page by page.

When you read them, ask who made each document, who it was for, and whose lives it leaves out. The notice and the pamphlet speak for the management and the union; the voices of the women, the children and the families who went south are quieter in the record, and worth listening for.

Written by Ifan First published Last updated